3 stars because while everything smelled wonderful I experienced poor service. After calling in the morning about a specific pie and being told they were first come first serve (couldn't even pay with my card over the phone!) I drove up there. Only to stand in line and watch as they pulled the last pie and HELD IT FOR SOMEONE ON THE PHONE. I pointed out this discrepancy and was scoffed at. After 2 workers consulted in a back room I was able to take the pie with much eye rolling and sighing on the counter lady's part. This poor customer service left a very bad taste in my mouth. I will not be back.