user
Potbelly Sandwich Shop
1200 Brown St #130, Dayton, OH 45409, United States
Appearance
Comments
Ri
Review №1

I just met of my two very best friends here for lunch. One of us recently had a family tragedy and the other 2 of us met him for support. I am not sure how, but Cecelia picked up on this (even behind masks). By the time we ordered and went to pay for our food, she said "lunch was on them".We were all amazed! She even took the time to come to our table after we were done eating to give us cookies and words of encouragement. Thank-you Cecelia, you have no idea how much that kind gesture meant to the three of us. ...oh, the food was also amazing!

Be
Review №2

This is a great place. I eat lunch here every so often. Friendly staff and savory sandwiches, what more could you ask for? Awesome milkshakes? They have those too. Get the app for rewards as well. I recommend the Wreck with everything on it.

Ri
Review №3

Family always enjoys Potbelly. They don't even get annoyed over our ridiculously complex sandwich orders.

Sa
Review №4

Today was my first time at Potbelly's and it was wonderful ! I placed my order online and went to the store . The cashier was super friendly and sweet . I did not have to wait for my food the order was ready upon arrival. When I arrived home the food was hot and very yummy !! I would highly recommend . The restaurant was clean and the food was amazing !

Ab
Review №5

Staff was incredibly kind and friendly and the food was delicious! I love the new choose two option! The mac and cheese was fantastic! It's been a while since my husband and I have been to Potbelly, but from such a lovely experience, it will be in my thoughts the next time we're trying to decide where to eat!

Si
Review №6

Order was ready the same millisecond the Spock up confirmation said which is the exact same millisecond I arrived. Also order was 100% correct. Thank you!

Ma
Review №7

Got there near six, it wasn't packed at all. Looking forward to returning with my relatives.

Sa
Review №8

The service was great, and the food was quite tasty! I'm a first time customer. I tried some soup (cold day & have a bit of a cold, so soup hit the spot)! It was fast, friendly, and yummy. I was even surprised at the register by the cashier saying "that will be taken care of by us today". I was very surprised and still not sure why they comped my lunch, but that generosity certainly made a repeat customer out of me. I was very impressed with the Brown St location!

La
Review №9

A big wreck and an Aranctiata Rosa is my jam! Always tasty, fast and sufficient.

Br
Review №10

Always Kind, polite, and courteous. They have some of the best shakes, in my opinion. Especially, there Oreo Shake!

Ev
Review №11

OMG, this is the best sandwich I've had in awhile! I ordered a toasted original Italian on multigrain bread, with ham substituted for the pepperoni. I had mustard, mayo, lettuce and tomatoes on it. It had a slight smoky flavor, like pizza sometimes does. The chocolate brownie cookie was to die for! It was soft, chewy and crispy. I'l definitely be back.

Je
Review №12

Love the mushroom melt sandwich

Da
Review №13

Sandwiches are amazing! Best tasting meat for your sandwich!

He
Review №14

Great quick lunch stop sandwiches are amazing

Ji
Review №15

Very good sandwich made well plenty of meat toasted choice of toppings would go back

Le
Review №16

Potbelly is a consistent, good sandwich shop. Staff are always friendly. The chili is a good addition to any meal. The food I've had has been tasty and they get customers through the line quickly. Milkshakes are very good, too. Kids love the seasonal mac and cheese. The only thing I'm never happy about is the amount of food for the price. It seems like sandwiches don't have a lot of meat or vegetables on them, which is a bit disappointing.

Au
Review №17

Quick, had Uber order ready!

Ke
Review №18

The service was fine but the sandwiches themselves tasted really bland. The potato soup was decent. Honestly prefer panera.

Pr
Review №19

Amazing food, clean and neat atmosphere. A bit pricey

Je
Review №20

I love potbelly, I always get the same thing. And now they offer delivery? Awesome!Called in, placed my usual order and was quoted $5 over what I pay in the store. I asked if that included tip or was just the delivery fee (because that's hefty); the lady taking my order did not know, and put me in touch with her manager. He confirmed that my total was incorrect and that he would wave the delivery fee &charge my card accordingly.40 minutes later I call in to confirm nothing has gone awry with my order; it has. The original order did not include the request to call upon delivery and the driver was not given a phone number, so now he cant find me. I'm glad I called when I did, so I go to get the food & I'm charged more than the manager confirmed with me. I still dont know if this is just the delivery fee or if a tip is included- no one ever answered that for me.But thankfully my food is still warm & delicious, but I do not think I will order delivery again. It was a wreck.

mo
Review №21

Their soups are yummy!

De
Review №22

No kids menu...food was ok

Tr
Review №23

Snuggled right in between the Brown Street // University of Dayton Plaza, PotBelly sandwich shop gives it's customers a unique dining experience. You basically have a delicious meal ahead of you regardless of what you pick. Wish the smoothies were healthier tho.

Ta
Review №24

Friendly staff, good food, clean place, easy in & out

Je
Review №25

Potbelly has a great atmosphere, good music but not too loud so its good place to get lunch and catch up. I get the pizza sandwich, which is consistently delicious. If you like your milkshakes thick then I'd skip getting one here. More milk than shake.

My
Review №26

Went in for an interview, seemed like a really cool, fun place to work. Really friendly staff and clean, homely environment. All in all, it wasn't a bad experience. If revisit and check out some of the many things on their menu.

Br
Review №27

Why have I not been here sooner. Love it!

Ke
Review №28

Very good. Excellent service. Parking terrible.

St
Review №29

Excellent sandwiches and friendly staff!!!!

Da
Review №30

Omg, I just had their broccoli cheddar soup. Yummy I usually visit Panera for their soup, but you guys have won over my tummy. Taste better and at a lower cost. Will be back

Am
Review №31

Stopped here for a quick lunch with my coworker while on a lunch break from our work convention at a nearby hotel. Food was delicious, prepared quickly with friendly service, and there was live music! Just a guy with a guitar but he was pretty good and his variety of song choices provided ample discussion with my coworker. There was plenty of seating, and the place was pretty clean overall (including the bathroom). Parking was a bit scarce, but we did eventually find a spot in the lot behind the building. Would definitely visit again if life/work provides another opportunity.

GG
Review №32

Went there and was completely ignored. Was just trying to get a table waited in line. No hostess took my name stood there for 20 minutes still no service. People getting help but not me. It was busy, so i can understand a wait but let me know you're saving a table when one comes available.

Lu
Review №33

Really good place to eat good subs

Ra
Review №34

Always tasty sandwiches, & good fast casual style service. I enjoy their cookies and shakes when I'm in the mood for a sweet treat. I also find the fun casual atmosphere, complete with guitar soloist at lunch sometimes, to be a nice break in my day. Overall, very good.

Et
Review №35

Literally like the best subs ever

Ro
Review №36

Ok. Pricy for what you get. Won't do it again

Er
Review №37

Good food, friendly staff

Sa
Review №38

Great place for a quick lunch or dinner. The salads are amazing.

Li
Review №39

Loved my half Italian and mac and cheese

Jo
Review №40

Best sandwich shop in Dayton! Staff is attentive and lines moves fast.

Cl
Review №41

Very good location. I had the skinny hammy and vegetable soup both very good and reasonable on calories. staff was very nice and very efficient.

L
Review №42

Just plain good.

De
Review №43

The mac and cheese is all the rage! The establishment is clean, employees are nice and the food is hot. Great service

Mo
Review №44

Good fresh food somewhat pricey especially since sandwiches are skimpy on the meat.

Am
Review №45

Very good sandwiches, nice staff, fast and clean.

Ed
Review №46

Their Mac n cheese cleanses my soul

Ri
Review №47

Consistently high quality food, and great salads. Not a local shop obviously, but the staff has ALWAYS made the experience great; definitely value added. I most often have the Farmer Salad. Parking in the shared lot can be sporty, but never failed to find a spot.

Jo
Review №48

Big wreck on wheat! Doesnt get better than that! Definitely try the macaroni salad!

an
Review №49

Mutha-lovin' POTBELLY!What more can I say? :-)

Ja
Review №50

I came in to potbelly fairly late tonight and Jose and Melinda welcomed with smiles! They are such good employees I would have been satisfied when if the food did taste all that great although it did! Thanks a bunch Jose and Melinda!!!

Ja
Review №51

Such a good sandwich & macaroni salad. Enjoyed the live music too.

de
Review №52

Great staff, and nice atmosphere. Loved my chocolate chip cookie.

Jo
Review №53

Great food, the sugar cookies are EVERYTHING

As
Review №54

Went here because Zombie Dogz was closed. Super impressed. Live music was fantastic!

He
Review №55

The website should tell you to call and check order status EXORESS you pick up. I ordered online for a specific time and still had to wait 20 minutes because they were too busy....great food though!

Li
Review №56

Best sandwich i ever had!

Ra
Review №57

Sandwich was excellent. Broccoli cheddar soup tasted spoiled. Restaurant was dirty. Trash on floor tables and food crumbs on the seats. When we walked in 3 employees were sitting at a table out front talking loudly. We felt ignored. We won't be back to this location.

Br
Review №58

Quixk and delicious

As
Review №59

I love Potbelly's! They have the best sandwiches and a great atmosphere!

Ka
Review №60

Love this place

Sa
Review №61

It's great!

On
Review №62

Great flavor...but the sandwiches are TINY!

Ka
Review №63

Their broccoli cheddar soup is AWESOME

Ma
Review №64

Good buffalo chicken sandwich

Ti
Review №65

Great food! I love going here for lunch.

ch
Review №66

When u say hit peppers make sure tell em not use whole jar lol peppers burnt me up but great service and food

Jo
Review №67

Great sandwich. Good milkshake

Mi
Review №68

Customer service was good but food was horrible and usually I like potbelly but today was different.

Ka
Review №69

Very tasty sandwiches. We need one of these in South Dayton area!!!!

Ma
Review №70

The Turkey club is to die for! Best subs around!

He
Review №71

Best sandwiches and their mac-n-cheese is AMAZING!!!

Ta
Review №72

Yummy

Ar
Review №73

It was great food was great

Jo
Review №74

Great sandwiches and milk shakes. Very fast service and tons of seating

Bi
Review №75

Wonderful place that will not break the bank. Better option than subway.

to
Review №76

I had a delicious Cuban sandwich.

fr
Review №77

Good food fast.

Ke
Review №78

Love this place great customer service!

Pa
Review №79

Get you some

Pa
Review №80

Expensive very skimpy on toppings meatball sub very bland

Mi
Review №81

Great soups and sandwiches

Em
Review №82

Good food and fast, the potato salad is amazing!

Ri
Review №83

Good

Ke
Review №84

Fast & delicious

Da
Review №85

Great

Jo
Review №86

Good food.

Bo
Review №87

Good place for a sub.

je
Review №88

Love the mushroom melt

An
Review №89

Great lunch spot

KA
Review №90

Nice food

pa
Review №91

Live this place friendly staff

je
Review №92

Food was great

Ri
Review №93

Great Subs!

Br
Review №94

Potbelly's

Se
Review №95

Subs

Do
Review №96

It was delicious

M
Review №97

Delicious sandwiches

De
Review №98

Yum yum yum yum

Te
Review №99

Great Food

st
Review №100

Great food

Information
11 Photos
100 Comments
4.5 Rating
  • Address:1200 Brown St #130, Dayton, OH 45409, United States
  • Site:http://www.potbelly.com/UniversityPlace?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=Yext
  • Phone:+1 937-220-9510
Categories
  • Caterer
  • Sandwich shop
  • Deli
Working hours
  • Monday:10AM–10PM
  • Tuesday:10AM–10PM
  • Wednesday:10AM–10PM
  • Thursday:10AM–10PM
  • Friday:10AM–10PM
  • Saturday:10AM–10PM
  • Sunday:10AM–10PM
Service options
  • Delivery:Yes
  • Dine-in:Yes
  • Takeout:Yes
Highlights
  • Live music:Yes
Popular for
  • Lunch:Yes
  • Dinner:Yes
  • Solo dining:Yes
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom:Yes
  • Wheelchair accessible seating:Yes
Offerings
  • Comfort food:Yes
  • Healthy options:Yes
  • Quick bite:Yes
  • Vegetarian options:Yes
Dining options
  • Lunch:Yes
  • Dinner:Yes
  • Catering:Yes
  • Dessert:Yes
  • Seating:Yes
Amenities
  • Good for kids:Yes
  • Restroom:Yes
Atmosphere
  • Casual:Yes
  • Cozy:Yes
Crowd
  • College students:Yes
  • Family-friendly:Yes
  • Groups:Yes
  • Tourists:Yes
Payments
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
Similar organizations